Mendelssohn’s Italian Symphony

Details

Antonín Dvořák

Romance in F Minor for Violin and Orchestra

Maureen Nelson, violin

William Walton

Sonata for String Orchestra (trans. Walton and Arnold)

Toggle open/close
Listen to Audio

Felix Mendelssohn

Symphony No. 4, Italian

Felix Mendelssohn was one of music’s most precocious prodigies, creating mature compositions while just a teenager. Still, at age 20, he did what most young men from wealthy families did at the time: He embarked on a “grand tour.” With extended visits to the British Isles and Italy, Mendelssohn expanded his worldview and brought home inspiration for future projects. Scotland would be memorialized in the Scottish Symphony and the Hebrides Overture, while Italy sparked an Italian Symphony. True to their origins, Mendelssohn’s Scottish works are misty and stormy, while the southern climate of Italy produced, in Mendelssohn’s words, “the jolliest piece I have ever done.”

Mendelssohn sketched part of the Italian Symphony while in Italy in 1830–31, and completed the work in 1833. He used the piece to fulfill a prestigious commission from the Philharmonic Society of London, the same group that had commissioned Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony. The Italian Symphony (the nickname came from the composer) debuted in London in May of 1834. Besides the clear, sunny nature of the work, especially in its ebullient first movement, Mendelssohn confirmed the Italian origins with specific folk references. He dubbed the finale a saltarello — a leaping Italian folk dance — and he also incorporated elements of a tarantella, a devilishly fast dance from southern Italy to be undertaken (so the story goes) after a bite from a tarantula, until the dancer is cured or dies.

Later in 1834, Mendelssohn made substantial revisions to the symphony’s final three movements. He intended to revise the first movement, too, but postponed that task. Eventually, he judged that too much time had passed for him to rework the first movement in a style consistent with the rest of the piece, so he suppressed the symphony altogether. The work was published posthumously as the Symphony No. 4, although it actually came after the First and Fifth symphonies and was followed by the Second and Third. To further complicate the matter, the publisher worked from the original London score instead of Mendelssohn’s revised version, which itself existed in various iterations. A scholarly edition based on Mendelssohn’s revisions finally came out in 1999, but it is quite a different work than the one the public knows. Clearly, Mendelssohn’s final intentions have been misrepresented over the years, but millions of fans who love the original Italian Symphony likely would not want a single note changed. This raises an age-old question: Is the composer the ultimate arbiter of his own music? In the case of a genius such as Mendelssohn, we can probably agree that any version of his work is a treasure to have in our repertoire.

Aaron Grad ©2009

About This Program

This program opens with new SPCO violinist Maureen Nelson soloing on Dvořák’s Romance in F Minor for Violin and Orchestra, a piece reworked from one of his earlier quartets. The Dvořák piece is followed by William Walton’s Sonata for String Orchestra, a transcription of his String Quartet in A Minor that the 20th century English composer completed with his colleague Malcom Arnold. The concert closes with Mendelssohn’s beloved Italian symphony.

SPECIAL PRE-CONCERT PERFORMANCE BY THE 2017 SPCO YOUTH CHAMBER MUSIC COMPETITION WINNERS ON APRIL 28

The winners of the 2017 SPCO Youth Chamber Music Competition, the Donovan Quintet, will perform in the Target Atrium of the Ordway Center during Fanfare preceding the Friday, April 28 performance of Mendelssohn’s Italian Symphony. The members of the quartet are Nadine Manske (violin), Cate Carson (violin), Edwin Patrick Thatcher Donovan (viola), Christopher Kwon (cello), and Nicholas Scheel (cello). They will be performing the third movement of Schubert’s String Quintet in C Major, D.956.

The annual competition is sponsored and coordinated by the Friends of the Saint Paul Chamber Orchestra, the volunteer organization that supports The SPCO through educational, social and fundraising activities. Partnering with them are MNSOTA (Minnesota String and Orchestra Teachers Association), and MacPhail Center for Music. To learn more about the competition and to hear the rest of this year's winners, visit www.spco-ycmc.org.